Map is loading...
3.5 / 5
Based on 2 votes

18 Bay

Restaurant in Shelter Island   Bar in Shelter Island  

Expensive Restaurant and Bar based at 23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Contacts: address, phone number and etc.

Price level Expensive
Address 23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Get directions
Phone number +1 631-749-0053
Website 18bayrestaurant.com

Opening hours Open now. Today: 05:30 pm — 10:00 pm

Sunday 05:30 pm — 10:00 pm
Monday 05:30 pm — 10:00 pm
Wednesday 05:30 pm — 10:00 pm
Thursday 05:30 pm — 10:00 pm
Friday 05:30 pm — 10:00 pm
Saturday 05:30 pm — 10:00 pm

Photos

Reviews about 18 Bay

  • 5 / 5
    By Ramirez Blanca
    Went there for dinner this evening for the first (but not the last) time. We had avoided trying it, despite the wonderful reviews, because we are not generally fans of a limited, fixed menu. Finally took the plunge, and even though management graciously offered to "break" the menu if we wanted, we decided to go whole enchilada. That was definitely the right choice. All the courses were chosen and portioned just right. Everything was extremely tasty and well-prepared. The entrees, pan-seared Cod for me and fork-tendered short rib for my Better Half were truly fabulous. Highly recommend.
    November 08, 2016
  • 2 / 5
    By David Lanzotti
    Pompous, overpriced, and rather other hyped, food did not live up to the "rave" reviews as my wife and I were thoroughly disappointed with our experience. Food was average, but factor in hassle of the ferry, and the owners inflated demeanor, you're left with an unsatisfied stomach and a boat ride home.
    October 07, 2016
How would you rate 18 Bay?

Menu of Restaurant and Bar 18 Bay

18 Bay is a expensive restaurant and bar based in Shelter Island, New York. To learn the menu, call the phone number indicated on the website.

If you visited this place, please leave your feedback. This will help other site visitors.